Dallas Sports Powerhouse






Monday, December 18, 2006

Are You Committing...Brother John?

The Horn football recruitment has pretty much mirrored their season. Both came out of the gate strong and both are showing signs of weakness towards the end. What initially seemed as the best all around recruitment class in the history of the 40 acres has started to fizzle. 2 solid verbal recruits have de-committed and another has had to hang up the shoulder pads due to medical reasons. The light at the end of the tunnel was that the #2 rated quarterback in the nation, John Brantley, still has a solid verbal with Texas.

In the words of the bumbling idiot Lee Corso...not so fast my friend.

Our friends at Burnt Orange Nation have published a very telling expose into the mind of the Brantley clan. Reading the comments, I too have come to the unfortunate conclusion that Brantley will not dawn the burnt orange. You have to look no further than Brantley's MySpace page to see other fan bases sending their well wishes. A viewing will also lead you to believe that his desire to come to Texas is still somewhat strong. But, best intentions do not automatically transfer into results.

What does this mean for Horn fans? A lot in this writer's opinion.

I am going to commit the sin of saying that Brantley would be more of an asset to this team than Colt McCoy is. I was very impressed with Colt's play this year, but he has questions still left to answer. As much as people want to dogpile on Greg Davis for his vanilla offense, it makes you wonder just how much faith he has in Colt's abilities. While he certainly has the name, look and poise to lead this team, Colt lacks the size and arm strength to make this team competitive for national contention. Were his stats Heisman worthy? Certainly. But, when you dissect his numbers, you see that the majority of his record breaking TDs were garnered against much weaker competition. Against this year's upper echelon (Ohio St., ou, Nebraska and a&m) Colt had 5 passing TDs and 4 interceptions. He also had a 2-2 record albeit extenuating circumstances for the two losses. As easy as it is to give Colt a pass, we must remember that he was a third ditch effort after Ryan Perriloux and Chase Daniel gave the Horns a cold shoulder. He simply exceeded the expectations considering what we lost.

Mr. McCoy, I served with John Brantley. I know John Brantley. John Brantley is a friend of mine. Mr. McCoy, you're no John Brantley.

Brantley has all the tools to be a winner. He is poised in the pocket and exudes flawless execution for his three time state championship team. He also has made it clear that he wants to sit on the bench for a year learning the offense. If Colt takes the next step to realizing his ceiling, Brantley would still have two years as the starting quarterback for Texas. Matt Leinert and Troy Smith seemed to have embraced this position quite nicely.

Despite the departure of Jevan Snead, Texas will be solid in the quarterback position. Even if verbal commit John Chiles decides to take his athleticism elsewhere, redshirt quarterback Sherrod Harris seems to be a competent heir to the throne. But, Brantley provides the same threat that national title contender Tim Tebow gives Florida. Should Colt's durability or endurance come into question again, it's nice to have as many aces in the sleeve as possible.

February cannot come soon enough.


Blogger J D Allen said...

"poised in the pocket and exudes flawless execution."

Dems big words for a high school quarterback. You think NFL teams have trouble evaluating QB talent? Look closely enough, and you'll see a high bust rate in college. Most people just don't keep nationwide recruiting lists in memory so as to see it te way they do the NFL draft.

I can read all I want on scout.com or rivals.com, but we won't know a thing about Brantley except he impressed some scouts playing against the best high schoolers in his state. Not the nations' best, mind you. The state.

Meanwhile, Perriloux was third on LSU's depth chart. Whatever happened to Tommy O'Grady (or whatever the forgotten QB's last name is)? These guys supposedly have all the tools.

Not to say questioning Colt's upside doesn't have some legitimacy, but I'm not banking on any high school recruit who may vanish from notice before he ever takes the field.

Besides if Colt takes a step back and Harris doesn't show much, suddenly you a potential QB opening that will draw next year's QB recruits.

10:44 PM  
Anonymous James said...

thats kind of inflating Colt's numbers, don't you think, calling him out for 4 INTs during those four games? 3 of them were in a single game, against A&M. That means that between the upper echelon (of which A&M shouldn't be included in the 1st place) he only threw 1 INT

8:15 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Main Menu

Scott Boswell
JD Allen
Jason Patlan
Jarred Dunn


Dallas Cowboys
Dallas Mavericks
Dallas Stars
Texas Rangers
Texas Longhorns
1310 The Ticket


July 2006 August 2006 September 2006 October 2006 November 2006 December 2006 January 2007 February 2007 March 2007 April 2007 May 2007 January 2009 February 2009

Friends of the Program

Burnt Orange Nation